In conclusion, I would like to forestall a possible concern that in historicizing information overload, I risk eliding the particularity of our own digital world and dismissing valid concerns, like Carr’s, about how we interact with our digital technologies. In highlighting the analogies between Google and Enlightenment print culture, I have attempted to resist the alarmism and utopianism that tend to frame current discussions of our digital culture, first by historicizing these concerns and second by demonstrating that technology needs to be understood in deep, embodied connection with the human. Considered in these terms, the question of whether Google is making us stupid or smart might give way to more complex and productive questions. What, for example, is the idea of the human person underlying Google’s efforts to organize the world’s information and what forms of human life does it facilitate?
One of his essay’s, “Is Google Making Us Stupid,” focuses on whether or not the Internet is creating problems within today’s society, and with our learning abilities in general.
Is Google Making Us Stupid Essay Sample - Bla Bla …
While one set of critics and bloggers used the UCLA study to dismiss the argument raised in Carr's essay, another set took a closer look at the conclusions that could be drawn from the study concerning the effects of Internet usage. Among the reflections concerning the possible interpretations of the UCLA study were whether greater breadth of brain activity while using the Internet in comparison with reading a book improved or impaired the quality of a reading session; and whether the decision-making and complex reasoning skills that are apparently involved in Internet search, according to the study, suggest a high quality of thought or simply the use of puzzle solving skills. Thomas Claburn, in , observed that the study's findings regarding the cognitive impact of regular Internet usage were inconclusive and stated that "it will take time before it's clear whether we should mourn the old ways, celebrate the new, or learn to stop worrying and love the Net".
Nicholas Carr- Is Google Making Us Stupid
Is Google Making Us Stupid?
Kari Smith, Ja'quaya Salley, Dayzia Gadson, Anthony Mitchell, Austin Parks
-How often do you use the internet?
-Which search engine do you prefer to use?
-Do you think the internet is making you stupid?
Is Google Making Us Stupid By Nicholas Carr Quotes
The essay of Nicholas Carr touched the problem the roots of which I’ve witnessed among my contemporaries and could trace in my thinking as well. Carr suggests that the specifics of reading and writing online does not only change our access to information, but also reprograms the way we are actually thinking. His arguments are properly and scientifically reasoned: the flexibility of human brain and the speed of adjustment to new conditions, as well as appropriate examples, are the proof of Carr’s ideas. The author suggests that currently it’s becoming more difficult for people to deal with long books and articles, to engage in reading for a long time and to dwell in deep consideration. He is making the readers aware of the superficiality the Web is imposing on everyone. The examples with the newspapers creating a second page with abstracts of texts and TV programs with blinking ads were quite impressive and show the pattern how the new medium of the Web shapes the offline reality. Carr does not only express his worries but provides many examples when philosophers could easily forecast the disadvantages of new discoveries like writing, printing, mechanical clock etc. but were unable to foresee the endless advantages of these discoveries. However, Carr expressed the alarm that connecting us to the artificial intelligence like the one that Google is willing to provide would not benefit each of us but would rather make human thinking resemble artificial one.
Is Google Making Us Stupid By Nicholas Carr quotes - 1
In Carr's 2008 book The Big Switch: Rewiring the World, From Edison to Google, the material in the final chapter, "iGod", provided a basis for his later magazine article titled "Is Google Making Us Stupid?". The inspiration to write "Is Google Making Us Stupid?" came from the difficulties Carr found he had in remaining engaged with not only books he had to read but even books that he found very interesting. This is sometimes called , a term coined by academic in his book The Gutenberg Elegies and later defined by developmental psychologist Maryanne Wolf with an added connotation.